The news that YouTube TV and NBCUniversal reached a last-minute deal to avoid a massive channel blackout was framed as a win for consumers. However, for those of us who cut the cord to escape cable company greed, it was just another frustrating chapter in the media industry's ongoing attempt to force us back into a costly bundle. The fact that a deal was struck at the eleventh hour is not a sign of value; it is a clear symptom that the virtual Multichannel Video Programming Distributor (vMVPD) model is fundamentally broken.
The recent negotiations, like countless ones before, demonstrate that vMVPDs like YouTube TV, Hulu+Live TV, and Fubo are now simply replicating the pricing and behavior of the old cable companies they were meant to replace.
The Cable Trap Lives On
The entire YouTube TV vs. NBCUniversal standoff was a prime example of carriage dispute brinksmanship. Millions of subscribers who rely on channels like MSNBC, CNBC, and USA Network for news and sports were held hostage right up to the midnight deadline on September 30th. For YouTube TV subscribers who pay around $83 per month, this constant threat is part of the hidden cost of "cutting the cord" with a bundled service.
The network owner, in this case NBCUniversal (which is spinning off many of these channels into a new company, Versant), is fighting fiercely to maintain the illusion that these channels are indispensable. They rely on the sheer terror of losing content to justify the high carriage fees they demand.
The $83 Burden
The price hike that inevitably follows a carriage dispute is built on a simple economic truth: vMVPDs must include virtually all linear networks to satisfy the broad audience, forcing every subscriber to subsidize niche channels they never watch.
NBC's Fragmentation Strategy
NBCUniversal’s approach is the antithesis of the modern consumer's desire for choice. While major content owners like Disney and Fox are moving toward consolidated, a-la-carte direct-to-consumer (DTC) offerings, NBCUniversal uses a fragmentation strategy to hold the bundle together.
The value of the threatened channels is not about the sheer volume of sports; it is about the specific, passionate audiences for two key live sports:
The USA Network Exclusivity
NBCUniversal withholds live access to critical events to ensure vMVPDs stay necessary:
- NASCAR Cup Series: The majority of the Cup Series races during the second half of the season that are under the NBC contract air exclusively live on the USA Network cable channel. These races are not streamed live on Peacock Premium.
- Premier League Soccer: Key Premier League matches are broadcast live exclusively on the USA Network. Peacock Premium subscribers who miss these games live must settle for viewing the replay the following day.
The sports content NBCU is using as leverage -- soccer, car racing, and golf -- combined makes up less than 9% of Americans' favorite sports. This means that 91% of the audience that names a favorite sport is being forced to subsidize content for a niche group.
The Cord-Cutter's Counter-Attack
The real story here is that smart streaming habits render these disputes meaningless.
Instead of paying for a bloated vMVPD, consumers can now get the essential sports channels for half the price:
- Fox One ($19.99/month): Includes the live feeds of Fox Sports, FS1, FS2, and the Big Ten Network.
- ESPN Unlimited ($29.99/month): Includes the live feeds of ESPN, ESPN2, ESPNU, SEC Network, and ACC Network, plus all ESPN Plus content.
- The Bundle Price: The two services are available bundled for a deeply discounted $39.99/month.
Add in an OTA antenna (which brings in all the local broadcast channels like NBC, CBS, and FOX), and the cord-cutter bypasses the entire NBCUniversal carriage feud, getting all of the highest-rated sports content for less than the cost of a basic cable bill from decades ago. The fact that YouTube TV subscribers are cheering for a short-term extension of a costly status quo only highlights the power of NBCUniversal's strategic content fragmentation. My Streaming Life is about curating my content for maximum value, to help ensure I never pay for a channel I don't truly need to watch live.
Comments
Post a Comment
Your comments are welcome. Abusive or off-topic comments will be removed.